Camera Choices Part 3 – which SLR

camera choices part 1

Back in Part 1 of this series of articles I mentioned that I would be revisiting SLR’s and here I will.

Many people consider the SLR to be King, it’s what people think of when you mention Priofesional Photography. But except for a few areas the SLR is in fact a Jack of all Trades but master of None.

Actually that’s a little unfair, there are two areas in which the SLR is hard to beat.

  • Wildlife & Macro
  • News Photography & Sport

It’s these two areas that continue to drive SLR design.

I am a Nikon user, so when it comes to SLR’s its the current professional Models I will look at.

Top of the tree is the D4. This is focused on performance, and while it does not have the Mega Pixel count of many other cameras, its speed of focus, reaction, and high ISO performance is unparalleled.

This camera can shoot at 11 frames a second in very low light situations. For photographers who have to get the shot, this camera will do its best to get you that shot.

But for some just getting the shot is not enough. What they want is the highest resolution that modern 35mm DSLR can produce. Every subtle of a feather on a bird wants to be resolved to its maximum. So for these Nikon produce two models the D800 and D800E. I have gone on enough about the advantages and disadvantages of the anti-alaising filter, the model D800E lacks this blur -adding filter for the ultimate in resolution but with the risk of Moire.

Lastly in the professional range of Nikon bodies, there is the D300s. This is not a full frame body but is a cropped body, giving a tighter angel of view the a full frame D4. Many treat this as a poor mans sport and wildlife camera. Good reach and fast, but it is getting old now.

  • D4
  • D800(E)
  • D300s

For my work of weddings, studio etc then the D800 seems to be the option, but for my wildlife then a D4 or D300s may be a better option.

So what would be my choice, well just before the D4 was released I would have been tempted by the D3, the D4 while an improvement I don’t like the loss of the second CF card slot, so now I would choose the D800, but it would have to wait. The D800 is 36 Mega Pixels, think new computer and backup drives before reaching for the wallet to buy the camera.

I have missed out a lot of other cameras, what about the D600, slightly lower Mega Pixels then the D800, you could get away with your current computer, but the auto focus system is not up to the standard of the D800 or D4, its been slightly crippled. Unfortunately as you work down a camera manufactures models they become more and more compromised.

I would rather concentrate on getting the shot then fighting the camera, its the top models that allow you to easier to do this.

So yes, when funds allow it will be a D800E unless a secondhand D3s appears at a bargain price.

February is here and a fresh start to the Year

Gull coming to LandAfter the Sunday at Boutham Park shooting wildlife, I have spent the last week in bed with a rather bad chest infection.  Not only did the boss send me home on the Monday but even the Doctor sent me to Hospital to get checked out further.

So most of last weeks Blog entries were all pre-written posts as I have spent the time asleep in bed.

This Monday I am now starting to feel better and i’ll be heading back to work on Tuesday now that I can face staring at a computer screen without my head exploding.

I am going to be thinking hard about what I am going to photography this year.  With this I’ll be considering my lens and where I have gaps in my current selection.

I have two trips planned so far, both landscape and wildlife focussed.  The first is a trip to the Forrest of Dean, the second which we will be planning over the next few weeks is a trip to the Shetland Islands.

For the Landscape I have the gear and equipment I need but will lookout for mild large format telephoto, possibly 200-300mm range.  For the SLR, I am going to keep my eye out for something a little longer then my 70-200mm f/2.8 and possibly add another teleconverter.

So here as I finishing writing this with one last coughing fit over the keyboard, i’ll also add one more lens into the mix, possibly a Leica 90mm.

 

Lens to consider this year.

Large format:

210mm or 300mm f/5.6

Digital SLR:

300mm f/2.8 or f/4

200mm /f2

Range Finder:

50mm f/2

90mm f/2

a trip to another local park – Boultham Park

Swans

Sunday we had plans for a walk at the coast, but with the snow on Friday night and then the heavy thaw the rivers were swollen, and some roads flooded.

So instead I decided to make a visit to another local park.  This time it was Boultham Park.  I have fond memories of this park as I used to live close by.  There used to be a lot there but in the 1980’s it became run down, but now its being restored again and is well worth a visit.

Ducks on the Mound

Chris was also up for a bit of bird photography so we met just after dawn at the park.

We entered the park from the church side and as we approached the lake we spotted our first wildlife, a group of Mallard Ducks.

Mallard Duck Feeding

Mallard Ducks Feeding

At first there was little light and most of my first shots were blurred even with the ISO cranked right up.

The Sun did eventually make an appearance, but photography was still difficult.  Because of the ice still covering most of the lake, the majority of birds we on the North side, so to get close we ended up having to shoot into the sun.  It was bright and contrasty causing issues with my exposure.

 

Ornamental Black Duck Ornamental White Duck

As we slowly made our way along the lake, the light improved and we spotted a number of interesting species of Duck as well as some Moorhen and Cootes.
Ornamental Duck Coote Gull coming to Land Black Headed Gull in Flight

Ducks on Ice
Ducks on Ice

White Duck

As you can see above, quite a productive day with some nice shots.  Yes they could have been a little better exposed and sharper, but Wildlife Photography in the cold and poor light of winter is trick, and for only my second trip out out of the year I am very pleased with the results.

Wildlife Photography on the Cheap

As I wrote the above title, I suddenly thought that I had it wrong.  My budget gear consists of a Nikon V1 system.  Actually this is not a cheap system, something like a Nikon D3100 and a 70-300mm lens would actually work out cheaper and better, but there are some amazing deals at the moment, and the discontinued V1 is now quite a bargain, unlike when it was first released.

The advantage of the Nikon 1 is its size and as I had commuted into Lincoln on my Motorcycle, the full Nikon 1 kit easily fits in my tank bag together with a change of clothes.

So Wildlife Photography on the Cheap, what do you need, well basically I have already said above, a camera has a bit of reach.  The Nikon 1 system is a very fast focusing mirror-less camera and while not as good as an SLR is an option for this type of thing if you can put up with its issues.

The other thing to consider is what you are photographing.  I know of a photographer that instead of a long lens uses bait to bring the wildlife to him.

Today instead of using bait, we had the benefit of ice.  I was photographing in the middle of Lincoln, by the Brayford Pool where I went Kayaking a few months ago.

With the cold weather a lot of the Brayford Pool is now iced over, this has forced the wildlife a lot closer to the bank enabling you to get some good shots with easy.

Camera Choices Part 2

So in my previous post on Camera Choices, I made some generalisations about what camera types I would use for each of my chosen genres.

But lets look at actual models.  If I had the unlimited funds for my GAS (Gear Acquisition Syndrome) what would I actually own.

First of all formats.  Which formats would I own.

  • Large Format
  • Medium Format
  • Small Format

Yes I would own them all.  No one camera can do all tasks well.

Large Format:

Ebony 45SU

 

45SU

Theres not a lot of difference between this model and my current 45S, this slightly more flexible and easier and faster to use.  I might add a PhaseOne digital back.  This is my ideal landscape camera.

 

Medium Format:

Part of me wants to say my current Hasselblad with a digital back which in many ways is a good solution for landscape work, the back could also be used on the Large Format Camera.  I want a Medium Format Camera for Weddings and Studio work, as fast to use as an SLR, so my choice is the Leica S.

 

Small Format:

With having the Leica S, then my Small Format camera would actually be several cameras.  First an SLR for Wildlife and Macro work.  Its a tough choice, I prefer Nikon to most other manufactures and it would between the D4 and the D800e, one might even have both, the D4 for wildlife and the D800e for Macro work.  A camera such as the D300s may possibly be a good choice to cover both areas but it getting a little old now and is ready for replacement.  I would be interested in how the D800 handles wildlife, is the frame rate and noise performance good enough.  I don’t know but I feel some testing is going to have to be done.

Next my high quality small mirror-less option, this is going to be a surprise for many but it would be the Leica Monochrom, yes a Black & White only camera.

Finally a Compact and I think it would be Sony RX1, a full frame compact.

Sony RX1

So those would be my choices if money was no option.

 

Camara Choices

I know a number of photographers who having been thinking long and hard about their gear choices.

Many are downsizing from large heavy DSLR’s to mirror-less, and there is now a mirror-less option for most people, but sometimes one camera cannot do everything.

Richard & Chris
Richard & Chris Shooting Wildlife

What do I photograph?

Well my professional work is quite a mix, from model portfolios like the shot below:

Charlotte in CS6

to weddings, portraits and even some event photographs like the shots below.

Jubilee Dress

Lincolnshire Show-9

My personal work is landscape especially architectural landscapes and street photography, with a bit of wildlife and macro thrown in for good measure.

20120524-211324.jpg

 

Now if you wanted to pick just one camera to do all this work then a professional DSLR would do the job but there are better choices.

Lets look at those subjects again.

  • Model Portfolios – Studio Work

I do a lot of studio photography, for myself as well as portraits for people and models. Your after quality, mega pixels, sharpness, a camera that can shoot quickly to respond to a sudden expression that might appear, but as studio flashes recycle slowly fast recovery and fast frame rate are not necessary.

I use an DSLR and keep thinking about upgrading to a D800 to gain the extra mega pixels but a Medium Format Camera would be the best choice. Now I own a Hasselblad Medium Format Camera but currently cannot justify the cost of a digital back. If money was no option then I would add a Leica S with a wide angle lens and a mid telephoto lens.

  • Weddings

Before digital most professionals used Medium Format, now its mainly Canon shooters with the great 5D; since the Nikon D3 and its high iso performance many now also use these. It can be dark in some of these churches. Shooting people can be an art and its interesting how people react to large cameras, a big digital SLR can put people off. Thats where Medium Format cameras with waist level finders come in, they can relax people more.

  • Event Photography

This depends on the subject, I have shot parties, corporate events, even horse riding. Here a good all rounder is needed and no camera is a better all-rounder then the Digital SLR.

 

  • Landscapes

Large Format - Hay after the Storm
For landscapes think big. Medium Format or even Large Format. Tilt and shift lens or a camera with movements can also help. Here I use either my Hasselblad or Ebony.

  • Street Photography

20120521-214417.jpg

For years people have used Leica’s for this. There is something to be said for a small camera. People react better. I know a professional studio photographer who uses a Leica in the studio instead of his digital Medium Format Camera. He feels the models react better. I also know a Wedding photographer who uses a Leica for the same reason. Also if shooting during the ceremony mirror-less cameras like the Leica are very quiet.

  • Macro Photography

Here the SLR rules, while some do use medium format and there are work-arounds available for others and live view is a major advantage to this kind of work.

Bee

  • Wildlife

Once again the SLR is king. There may be certain subjects where other cameras may give you an advantage generally the SLR rules. While you can sometimes get good images like the one below which was taken with a Nikon D200 and a 200mm f/2.8 lens with a x1.4 teleconverter, bigger is better, and a Nikon D3s with a 800mm f/4 lens is hard to beat.

Heron

 

So what cameras should I own

  • Model Portfolios – Studio Work

Best: Medium Format
General: Digital SLR
Alternative: Mirror-less

  • Weddings

Best: Medium Format
General: Digital SLR
Alternative: Mirror-less

  • Event Photography

Best: Digital SLR
General: Mirror-less

  • Landscapes

Best: Large Format
General: Medium Format
Alternative: Digital SLR or Mirror-less

  • Street Photography

Best: Mirror-less
General: Digital SLR
Alternative: Medium Format

  • Macro Photography

Best: Digital SLR
General: Medium Format
Alternative: Mirror-less

  • Wildlife

Best: Digital SLR
General: Mirror-less
Alternative: Medium Format

Looking at this list and what I shoot professionally and personally, then a digital Medium Format Camera is what I should be using for most of my work, with possibly a Leica acting as the mirror-less option.

Problem with all that is cost. With good digital Medium Format cameras at £20k and the lens at £5k a pop its just not an option. So I will keep looking at second hand digital backs to add to my old Hasselblad. Until then I will continue to use the good all rounder, the SLR. I will start using the Leica for none essential work as the quality is very high, but its slower and sometimes automation can help.

For Landscapes, using film on my Medium Format and Large Format Cameras is still a good option, even using the Leica is a good choice.

Looks like an excuse to keep all my current cameras!

I would like to replace one of the D200’s, there are getting old now and the ISO performance when shooting Weddings and Wildlife is not always what I would like, but what with? Well thats a discussion for another day.

First Wildlife Practice Trip of 2013

With the weather proving an interesting back drop and Chris wanted to practice some bird photography, I packed my largest heaviest tripod, my longest lens together with my Nikon D200 and a Leica M4 for snapshots and headed out to our local park, Hartsholme.

flight over ice

After the snow of Friday, the roads were well cleared but the park still looked lovely in its white cloak.

I decided on a late start and Chris’s car was already in the car park. Dressed in warm winter clothing, my tripod with D200 mounted over my right shoulder and my Leica M4 over my left, I headed out to the lake.

Birds as Art

Light was relatively poor and I was having to shoot close to the limits of my ISO for the D200.  The poor light, strong contrast from the snow and darkness of the trees, the images looked Black & White.  The shot above I actually converted to Black & White and increased the contrast, hoping to make an average image slightly more Arty.

Gull in Flight - 2

As I setup Chris appeared, he had been shooting here a while further along the lake.  We then waited to see what would appear.

Gull in Flight - 1

Birds in flight are very tricky.  I set ISO to auto and had the mode set to Shutter priority camera.  Depending on what the action was, I switched the shutter speed from 1/125s to 1/800s.

Gulls over Ice

A lot of my early shots were blurred, or out of focus but as the morning progressed I gradually began to get my technique back.

Duck on Ice

Wildlife photography is tricky and requires a good knowledge of your camera, how to configure its autofocus, auto iso and modes to increase your chance to get the shots you want.

Its not just knowing your equipment but you can greatly increase your chances of getting a good shot by knowing your location and knowing your subject well.

A cold but enjoyable day and considering the lighting conditions and my lack of practice I am quite pleased with my results.